> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.bestfirms.org/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Best Employee Scheduling Software in 2026: Ranked by Job, Price, and Whether $2.50 Is a Seat or a Location
- URL: https://www.bestfirms.org/best-employee-scheduling-software-2026/
- Published: 2026-08-21T06:25:53.000Z
- Updated: 2026-08-21T06:25:53.000Z
- Description: When I Work, Deputy, Homebase, and Sling solve different jobs. We ranked 4 shift platforms by per-user vs per-location vs free-tier cliff, and what a $0–$9 seat or a $24–$96 location actually keeps after the 11th employee, the $30 floor, and the $100 clopening.
- Author: Best Firms Editorial
- Tags: HR Tech, Business, Startups, Technology, Payroll, Rankings, Guides

Employee scheduling software is not [appointment scheduling](https://www.bestfirms.org/best-appointment-scheduling-software-2026). It is not a [time tracker](https://www.bestfirms.org/best-time-tracking-software-2026). It is a rota, a swap, a clock that may or may not sit on the same invoice, and a bill that grows when you add a head — or a door. The Google query treats When I Work, Deputy, Homebase, and Sling as rivals. They are not. One meters **users**. One meters **users**, then a **$30 floor**, and it bills the manager. One meters **locations** and gives you **10 people free** until the 11th employee or the second address. One gives you **30 users free** and sells the clock on Premium. Mix those jobs and you pay twice — once for the plan, and again when the city charges **$10–$75** for a schedule you changed inside 14 days, or **$100** for a clopening the tool was happy to publish.

**Key Takeaways**

- **There is no overall best.** Rank by job: cheap per-head rota, compliance-and-forecast seat, per-location unlimited heads, or a $0 schedule that stops at the clock.
- **The market splits in four.** When I Work, Deputy, Homebase, Sling.
- **The sticker is a billing unit, not a category.** [When I Work from $2.50/user](https://wheniwork.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org). [Deputy from $5, $30 floor](https://www.deputy.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org). [Homebase $0 to 10 people / one address, then $24–$96 yearly](https://www.joinhomebase.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org). [Sling Free to 30 users; Premium from $1.70 yearly](https://getsling.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org).
- **A late change is a wage.** The [DOL](https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/overtime?ref=bestfirms.org) requires **time and one-half after 40 hours in a workweek**. NYC [Fair Workweek](https://www.nyc.gov/site/dca/businesses/fairworkweek-deductions-laws-employers.page?ref=bestfirms.org) requires **14 days' notice**, **$10–$75** change premiums, and a **$100** clopening.

## What employee scheduling software is (and what it is not)

The product is a closed loop: availability → published rota → swap or callout → clock (optional) → timesheet → [payroll](https://www.bestfirms.org/best-payroll-platforms-for-startups-2026-review) file. That is not [appointment scheduling](https://www.bestfirms.org/best-appointment-scheduling-software-2026) (a client picks a slot). It is not [time tracking](https://www.bestfirms.org/best-time-tracking-software-2026) sold as billable hours or screenshots. Two jobs share the label: a **shift publisher** and a **labor-compliance engine** (break rules, clopenings, demand forecast, the 14-day notice). When I Work and Sling Free are built for the first. Deputy Core is built for the second. Homebase is a location SKU that becomes HR only on All-in-One. Buy the first for a 30-store forecast and you rebuild the rules. Buy the second for a 10-person cafe and you pay a seat floor before the first swap.

## How we ranked

Five checks, not a composite score: **job**, **whether a price is published**, **what the meter is (user vs location)**, **what the free floor keeps**, and **real annual cost**. Prices checked against official pages on 21 August 2026\. Annual billed rates first where published.

## Quick picks by job

**A published per-head rota under $3.** When I Work Essentials at **$2.50 per user per month**. 14-day trial. No lasting free plan.

**Labor rules, auto-scheduling, and a forecast.** Deputy Core at **$6.50**. Lite at **$5** is the clock-and-swap SKU. Budget the **$30** floor and every admin seat.

**One shop, unlimited heads, a location bill.** Homebase. Free until **10 employees** on **one** address. Essentials at **$24 a month billed yearly** the minute you hire the 11th or open a second door.

**A $0 schedule for up to 30 people.** Sling Free: shifts, swaps, time-off. The clock is **Premium at $1.70** billed yearly. Sling is now **Sling by Toast**.

## Comparison: 4 platforms

| Tool             | Type                    | Starting price                                                                                      | Best for                             | Main trap                                                                                                                                          |
| ---------------- | ----------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| When I Work      | Per-user scheduling     | Essentials $2.50/user/mo; Pro $5; Premium $8; 14-day trial                                          | Cheapest published seat              | Pricing page shows a **Time Tracking & Attendance toggle**; the FAQ says every plan includes the clock. Confirm before you model $2.50 as punch-in |
| Deputy           | Per-user WFM            | Lite $5; Core $6.50; Pro $9; **$30/mo minimum**                                                     | Break rules and auto-scheduling      | **Admins count.** New, archived, and unarchived users bill the **full month**. SMS is **1¢** (US) / 160 characters                                 |
| Homebase         | Per-location            | Free (1 location, 10 employees); Essentials $30 / $24 yearly; Plus $70 / $56; All-in-One $120 / $96 | One shop that grows heads, not doors | The 11th employee or the second address ends Free. Payroll is **$39 + $6** per paid employee                                                       |
| Sling (by Toast) | Per-user, free schedule | Free (30 users); Premium $2 / $1.70 yearly; Business $4 / $3.40                                     | Teams that will live on a $0 rota    | Free is **scheduling**, not the clock. The 31st user is Premium                                                                                    |

## Cheap per-head rota: When I Work

Right buy when the job is a published week, swaps, and a number you can defend at $2.50 a head. Wrong buy as the Fair Workweek rules engine, and wrong buy if you assumed the clock was in the sticker.

[Essentials is $2.50 per user per month](https://wheniwork.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org): auto-scheduling, multi-week templates, OpenShifts and swaps, messaging. [Pro is $5](https://wheniwork.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org): scheduling rules, role permissions, custom reporting. [Premium is $8](https://wheniwork.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org): API, SAML/SSO. 14-day trial, no card. No printed annual rate.

Trap: **The big number is scheduling.** Each plan shows a Time Tracking & Attendance toggle; the FAQ says the clock is included. Those two sentences cannot both be the invoice. Confirm the toggle before you model $2.50 as punch-in.

## Compliance seat, $30 floor: Deputy

Right buy when the job is breaks, auto-scheduling, demand, and a timesheet you will defend. Wrong buy for a six-person shop that will hit the floor before it hits five seats.

[Lite is $5 per user per month](https://www.deputy.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org) (USD, excl. tax): scheduling, timesheets, clock, labor-law compliance, swaps. [Core is $6.50](https://www.deputy.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org): auto-scheduling, demand forecasting, wage budgets. [Pro is $9](https://www.deputy.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org): SSO, Analytics+ and Messaging+. Add-ons: HR **$2**, Payroll **$8 per user plus $49/mo** on annual Core/Pro in the US.

Trap: [**A $30 monthly minimum applies from 1 September 2025**](https://www.deputy.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org)**.** Four people on Lite is $30, not $20\. **Admins count.** Add, archive, or unarchive mid-month and you still owe the full month. Annual plans cannot drop seats. SMS is **1¢ USD per 160 characters**.

## Per-location, free-tier cliff: Homebase

Right buy when one address will add heads, not doors, and you want the clock on the same SKU as the rota. Wrong buy as a five-location franchise on All-in-One.

[Basic is $0](https://www.joinhomebase.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org) for **one location and up to 10 employees**: basic scheduling, basic time tracking, POS. [Essentials is $30, or $24 billed yearly](https://www.joinhomebase.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org): unlimited employees, advanced scheduling and time tracking. [Plus is $70 / $56 yearly](https://www.joinhomebase.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org): AI scheduling, PTO. [All-in-One is $120 / $96 yearly](https://www.joinhomebase.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org): onboarding, labor-cost, HR. Payroll add-on: **$39/mo + $6 per paid employee**.

Trap: **The free plan dies on the 11th badge or the second lock.** Two cafes with six people each are two location bills. PTO is Plus. Hiring is not an [ATS](https://www.bestfirms.org/best-applicant-tracking-systems-2026).

## Free schedule, paid clock: Sling

Right buy when 30 names on a rota is the product and nobody is punching in yet. Wrong buy as the kiosk and the payroll export.

[Free is $0 for up to 30 users](https://getsling.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org): shifts, time-off, swaps. [Premium is $2 per user, or $1.70 billed yearly](https://getsling.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org): mobile time tracking, overtime. [Business is $4, or $3.40 yearly](https://getsling.com/pricing?ref=bestfirms.org): kiosk clock, payroll reports, PTO. Deactivated users **prorate**. Branded **Sling by Toast**.

Trap: **Free's 30-user cap is not a clock.** Punch-in is Premium. The $0 rota will still publish a close-then-open that NYC prices at **$100**. A Toast shop should confirm the SKU is not already on the restaurant invoice.

## Worked annual cost at published floors

Assumptions: U.S. shop, annual billing where published. When I Work at the Essentials sticker (no printed annual). Deputy Lite, including the $30 floor. Homebase yearly. Sling yearly.

| Situation                               | When I Work                                | Deputy                               | Homebase                           | Sling                           |
| --------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------- | ------------------------------- |
| 8 people, 1 location, schedule only     | $240 ($2.50 × 8 × 12)                      | **$360** ($30 floor × 12)            | **$0** (Basic)                     | **$0** (Free)                   |
| 11 people, 1 location, schedule + clock | $330 sticker; confirm T&A toggle           | $660 ($5 × 11 × 12)                  | **$288** (Essentials $24 × 12)     | $224 (Premium $1.70 × 11 × 12)  |
| 25 people, 1 location                   | $750                                       | $1,500                               | **$288**                           | $0 schedule / $510 clock        |
| 3 locations, 15 people each (45)        | $2,700 at the FAQ's $5 multi-location seat | $2,700 Lite, plus every manager seat | **$864** (Essentials $24 × 3 × 12) | $918 (Premium; Free dies at 31) |

At 25 hourly names in one shop, Homebase Essentials is **$288 a year** and When I Work Essentials is **$750** before the clock toggle. That is a meter gap, not a quality gap. At eight people, Deputy's **$30 floor** is a $120/year tax versus $5 × 8\. At three doors, the location SKU wins until you need Deputy's auto-scheduler.

## When it breaks

**The billing unit is not the job.** When I Work and Deputy sell seats. Homebase sells locations. Sling sells seats with a 30-user free cap. A [SaaS spend](https://www.bestfirms.org/saas-spend-management-how-to-cut-20-without-breaking-workflows) review that compares “$2.50 vs $24” without naming the unit is a fiction.

**A free plan is a cliff.** Homebase: 10 people, one address. Sling: 30 users, no clock. When I Work: no free plan, 14 days. Deputy: no free plan, $30 floor. The 11th hire is an Essentials event.

**The manager is a seat.** Deputy bills administrators. Homebase does not bill heads on paid tiers. Count the people who build the rota, not just the people on it.

**A clock is a different SKU.** When I Work's toggle vs FAQ. Sling Free vs Premium. Homebase and Deputy put a clock on the floor SKU. Buying [Toggl to replace a missing punch-in](https://www.bestfirms.org/best-time-tracking-software-2026) gives you billable hours, not a shift swap.

**7shifts does not print a lasting dollar.** If the RFP needs a published rate, stay in the table above.

**FLSA does not care which app published the week.** The [DOL](https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/overtime?ref=bestfirms.org): unless exempt, covered employees get **at least time and one-half** for hours over **40 in a workweek**. The workweek is **168 hours**. **Averaging across two weeks is not permitted.**

**Fair Workweek is why the 14-day publish exists.** [NYC DCWP](https://www.nyc.gov/site/dca/businesses/fairworkweek-deductions-laws-employers.page?ref=bestfirms.org) (fast food, chain of **30+** nationally): **14 days' notice**, premiums for changes and clopenings, current staff first on new hours. The [official FAQ](https://www.nyc.gov/assets/dca/downloads/pdf/workers/FAQs-FairWorkweek-FastFood.pdf?ref=bestfirms.org) (15 September 2023) prices employer-made changes at **$10 / $15 / $15** for added hours and **$20 / $45 / $75** for reduced hours at <14 days / <7 days / <24 hours. A clopening (<**11 hours** between close and open) needs written consent **and** a **$100** premium. Unpaid premium: the premium plus **$300**. Consent does not waive it. An employee-requested swap does.

## A 15-minute way to choose

1. Write the job: publish a week, enforce breaks and 14-day notice, or keep one shop under a location bill.
2. Under 10 people, one address, clock included: Homebase Basic at $0\. Leave at 11 or at the second door.
3. Under 30 people, schedule only: Sling Free. Premium at $1.70 the minute someone punches in.
4. Cheapest published seat, and you will confirm the clock toggle: When I Work Essentials at $2.50.
5. Multi-site rules and auto-scheduling: Deputy Core at $6.50\. Model Lite at $5 plus the $30 floor and every manager.
6. Restaurant POS labor: open 7shifts and read the live quote. Covered fast food in NYC: publish 14 days out and price clopenings at $100\. Fail the meter, change lanes.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### What is the best employee scheduling software in 2026?

There is not one. When I Work Essentials at $2.50 a user for a cheap published rota (confirm the clock toggle). Deputy Lite at $5 — or Core at $6.50 — when rules are the job, after the $30 floor. Homebase Basic at $0 for one location and 10 people; Essentials at $24 yearly after that. Sling Free up to 30 users if you do not need a clock.

### When I Work vs Deputy: which one?

When I Work if the object is a $2.50 seat and a swap. Deputy if the object is break compliance, auto-scheduling, and a forecast. Deputy bills managers and enforces a $30 minimum. When I Work's clock is a toggle the FAQ contradicts. Neither is [Calendly](https://www.bestfirms.org/best-appointment-scheduling-software-2026).

### Is there a good free employee scheduling plan?

Homebase Basic: **one location, 10 employees**, basic clock. Sling Free: **30 users**, schedule only. When I Work and Deputy: trials only. A shared Google Sheet is not employee scheduling software.

## Methodology

We compared 4 platforms on job, published price, billing unit (user vs location), free-tier floor, and annual cost. Official pages checked on 21 August 2026: When I Work $2.50 / $5 / $8; 14-day trial; T&A toggle vs FAQ. Deputy $5 / $6.50 / $9; $30 minimum from 1 September 2025; admins count; full-month add/archive; SMS 1¢ / 160 characters; Payroll $8 + $49\. Homebase $0 (1 location, 10 employees) / $24 / $56 / $96 yearly; Payroll $39 + $6\. Sling Free (30 users) / $1.70 / $3.40 yearly. 7shifts public page interactive — no lasting printed dollar. Primary sources: U.S. DOL, *Overtime Pay*; NYC DCWP Fair Workweek employer page and FAQ (15 September 2023) — $10–$75 premiums, $100 clopening, $300 for unpaid premium. No bake-off. Not legal advice.